Your body does not have to explain itself first

On tension, high masking, and what can change without us knowing exactly how.
In the arena, we touch on something the client finds difficult.
It shows in the body straight away. The horse responds. I see it, feel it, and open myself to what is happening in the contact.
We do not have to move on immediately. No need to explain, fix, or turn it into a good story right now. Sometimes we just stay with it for a while.
And then something shifts.
Someone burps. Passes wind. A gut starts rumbling, loud enough to hear.
What exactly is happening there?
I don't know.
I notice that something is moving. I do not have to turn that into "trauma leaving the body" on the spot. Nor do I have to set it aside because I cannot point to the mechanism.
If you are used to explaining everything before it is allowed to exist, this piece is for you.
Between two big titles
The Body Keeps the Score (Van der Kolk, 2014) has given many people language for the bodily side of traumatic experience. There is now also a scientific opinion paper titled The Body Does Not Keep the Score, co-authored by Karl Friston among others. The authors propose understanding persistent trauma symptoms as threat predictions that have become too rigid, rather than as a literal bodily archive. They describe their own contribution as a reframing rather than a direct refutation (Kotler et al., 2026a).
That distinction matters.
It is one thing to say that experiences continue to affect us bodily. It is another to say that a body stores a specific memory. It is another again to say that you can read off what someone went through from a bodily reaction. That last conclusion does not follow from how real or how intense a sensation is. The correction to the opinion paper makes the same point: the intensity of a bodily response says nothing, by itself, about what actually happened (Kotler et al., 2026b).
But between "the body keeps everything" and "the body keeps nothing", something is at risk of disappearing: attention to what is actually going on.
You do not have to steer your body consciously
A body can carry a child. Heal a broken bone. Grow hair.
You do not need to know which cells exchange which signals when. During pregnancy, mother, placenta, and foetus coordinate their hormonal processes (Tal & Taylor, 2021). In bone healing, immune cells, blood vessels, bone-forming cells, and nerves work together. Hair growth is regulated in part by local signalling between cells in the follicle.
We can describe more and more of these parts.
That is not the same as fully understanding the living whole.
When I speak of the wisdom of the body, I do not mean an all-knowing inner doctor. I mean those capacities themselves: organising, attuning, maintaining, repairing, without our conscious direction. And my awe at them.
Yes, something in that can get stuck.
That is not a footnote to my work. That is where my work begins.
For those who became good at adapting
I am writing mainly for high-maskers.
You may recognise this: you can explain precisely what is going on. You have thought about it, made the connections, found the words. You know how to come across and what is expected of you.
But that does not yet mean you feel free to notice what is happening without correcting it at once.
In my work I do not want bodily experience to become yet another performance. That you have to feel properly. Visibly relax. Have a breakthrough that I can then recognise.
A burp is not a diploma. Calming down is not proof that you are doing it right.
For many of the high-maskers I work with, not knowing what is happening is not a neutral state. Knowing was, for a long time, the way to stay safe: reading what is expected, anticipating what comes, never being caught out. Letting something happen in your body without understanding it then does not feel like relaxation. It feels like danger.
In the arena I see that turn. Not all at once. First the discomfort becomes bearable. Then someone notices that not understanding does not have to mean that something is wrong. And sometimes, not knowing becomes a relief rather than a threat: for a moment, you do not have to carry it.
So the question is: can there be room for what you notice, without having to make it understandable, fitting, or useful right away?
There are measurable changes too
The Horsepower study followed veterans with persistent PTSD symptoms after earlier treatment. During a programme of equine-assisted activities, PTSD symptoms and sleep problems decreased and perceived health improved. The improvements were still visible at follow-up. During free interaction with the horses, heart rate was lower and heart rate variability higher in later weeks than in the first week, consistent with adaptation to acute arousal (Kapteijn et al., 2026).
The study had no control group and examined a whole programme. It therefore does not establish which component caused which change. Nor does it prove what burping or a rumbling gut means.
But uncertainty about the mechanism is not the same as absence of measurable change.
And a change at group level is not the same as a demand on the person standing in front of me.
A model meets a person
Scientific models help us look. They shape which questions we ask and what we measure.
Still, a group average does not automatically describe the person in front of us. Within PTSD, too, there are large differences: research on individual brain networks shows that shared patterns at group level go together with substantial variation between people (Suo et al., 2024).
That is why I want to keep two questions open.
Not only: does this observation fit our explanation?
Also: does our explanation fit this person, in this situation, well enough?
In the arena, for me, that means looking, listening, and not confusing my own impressions with the other person's experience. Inquiring without fixing everything in advance.
I do not need to know what every gut sound means.
What I do want to prevent is someone having to learn, once again, to ignore their experience because it does not yet fit neatly into our description.
Your body does not have to explain itself before we are allowed to pay attention to it.
References
- Kapteijn, C. M., Vermetten, E., Rodenburg, T. B., & Endenburg, N. (2026). Horsepower: Equine-assisted interventions are associated with reduced PTSD symptoms, improved sleep quality, and quality of life in military veterans with treatment-resistant PTSD. Frontiers in Psychology, 17, 1768001. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1768001
- Kotler, S., Mannino, M., Fox, G., & Friston, K. (2026a). The body does not keep the score: Trauma, predictive coding, and the restoration of metastability. Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience, 20, 1812957. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnsys.2026.1812957
- Kotler, S., Mannino, M., Fox, G., & Friston, K. (2026b). Correction: The body does not keep the score: Trauma, predictive coding, and the restoration of metastability. Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience, 20, 2015379. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnsys.2026.2015379
- Suo, X., Pan, N., Chen, L., Li, L., Kemp, G. J., Wang, S., & Gong, Q. (2024). Resolving heterogeneity in posttraumatic stress disorder using individualized structural covariance network analysis. Depression and Anxiety, 2024, 4399757. https://doi.org/10.1155/2024/4399757
- Tal, R., & Taylor, H. S. (2021). Endocrinology of pregnancy. In K. R. Feingold et al. (Eds.), Endotext. MDText.com. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK278962/
- Van der Kolk, B. (2014). The body keeps the score: Brain, mind, and body in the healing of trauma. Viking.
Article with references.
Originally published on LinkedIn.
Also available in Dutch: Je lichaam hoeft zich niet eerst te verklaren.
Read more on the site: neurodivergence, trauma & PTSD.
